Skip to main content

3 underrated shows on Hulu you need to watch in May 2024

Dan Stevens in Legion.
FX

Out of the major streamers, Hulu is perhaps the most well-rounded in terms of its lineup of shows and movies. Hulu may not be able to match Netflix’s volume, but its originals also tend to have higher quality than its competitor’s. Even the library shows on Hulu are strong, thanks in part to FX’s diverse lineup of shows.

This month’s picks for the three underrated shows on Hulu that you have to watch in May include FX’s one and only superhero show, a documentary, and a mystery drama. Between these three shows, you’ll have more than enough to binge this month.

Recommended Videos

Black Twitter: A People’s History (2024)

W. Kamau Bell in Black Twitter.
Hulu

Before some billionaire decided that Twitter ‘s iconic name should be rebranded as “X,” it was the social media platform for an even larger number of users than it is today. Hulu’s Black Twitter: A People’s Journey is a three-part documentary about the Black community’s role in the rise of Twitter, and how the platform led to cultural touchstone events like Black Lives Matter.

W. Kamau Bell, Amanda Seales, Jemele Hill, Roxane Gay, Sam Jay, Brad Jenkins, Alicia Garza, and April Reign are among the subjects who provide the oral history of Black Twitter. This miniseries also looks back at the highs and lows of this era for Twitter, while underscoring its important role that reached beyond social media and into real life.

Watch Black Twitter: A People’s History on Hulu .

Past Lies (2024)

The cast of Past Lives.
Hulu

You may get some déjà vu from Past Lies if you’re a fan of Showtime’s Yellowjackets . The premise of each show isn’t an exact match for the other’s, but they do share some common themes, as well as flashbacks to decades earlier with the main characters played by much younger performers. In the present, famous filmmaker Rita Montero (Elena Anaya) comes back to her hometown to deal with her mother’s estate. And it isn’t long before Rita is reunited with her former friends, Teresa (Belén Cuesta), Sole (Marta Etura), Carmen (Ana Rayo), and Lena (Lorena López).

The friends have largely been estranged for years over the fate of Mati Rios (Laura Wedel), who disappeared two decades earlier. Now that Mati’s body has finally been found, her cause of death won’t be the only secret that comes out. Mati’s younger sister, Detective Paula Rios (Irene Escolar), wants answers about what happened to her sister, and she’ll do anything to get them.

Watch Past Lies on Hulu .

Legion (2017-2019)

Dan Stevens and Aubrey Plaza in Legion.
FX

Since X-Men ’97 has reignited the general public’s interest in Marvel’s mutant heroes, it’s time to revisit one of the best corners of that franchise. Legion exists outside of the 20th Century Fox  X-Men movies, and yet its main character, David Heller (Dan Stevens), is the son of X-Men founder Charles Xavier. David may also be one of the most powerful mutants in the world, but his mental illness keeps him from his full potential.

Fargo ‘s Noah Hawley developed Legion for television, and it’s a non-superhero take on mutants that we haven’t really seen before. Aubrey Plaza co-stars as David’s friend, Lenny, who isn’t all that she appears to be. Whenever Plaza appears, she lights up the screen and adds some humor to the show. With only three seasons under its belt, Legion only had 27 episodes. But it’s still one of the best Marvel TV shows ever made .

Watch Legion on Hulu .

Blair Marnell
Blair Marnell has been an entertainment journalist for over 15 years. His bylines have appeared in Wizard Magazine, Geek…
Everything leaving Hulu in May 2025
Thomas Jane sits on a horse with a gun.

After months of dropping lesser-known movies at the end of the month, Hulu is shedding considerably more movies in May. Most of the films exiting Hulu in May are documentaries, including Gamestop: Rise of the Players, The Capote Tapes, and All the Streets Are Silent: The Convergence of Hip Hop and Skateboarding.
As with the previous months in 2025, most of the scripted movies exiting Hulu may have completely escaped your notice. How many movie lovers knew that John Travolta starred in Mob Land? Or that Alicia Silverstone has her Jaws moment in The Requin? Those films can be discovered now, but they aren't necessarily up to the stars' usual standards.

To help you make your viewing plans for the month, we're sharing our guide to everything leaving Hulu in May. Our picks for the month are in bold.

Read more
3 great Hulu movies you need to stream this weekend (February 28-March 2)
Keith Kupferer and Katherine Mallen Kupferer in Ghostlight.

The Oscars are coming this Sunday, March 2. In honor of cinema's version of Super Bowl Sunday, two of our picks for the three great Hulu movies that you need to stream this weekend are Oscar-nominated films from decades ago. The catch is that neither of those movies will be available on Hulu until March 1.
In the meantime, you can catch our first pick of the week, the acclaimed drama Ghostlight, on Hulu right now. It may not have been Oscar-nominated, but this was one of the best films of 2024.

Need more recommendations? We also have guides to the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
Ghostlight (2024)

Read more
The best shows on Hulu right now (May 2025)
Michelle Williams sitting at a table in a restaurant on her phone in Dying For Sex.

There are some great shows returning with new seasons this month, including Welcome to Wrexham and Nine Perfect Strangers. You'll also want to check out highly rated new shows like Dying for Sex, which stars Michelle Williams in her return to the small screen. But these aren't your only options if you're looking for something exciting to watch. The best shows on Hulu right now include a mix of new titles along with legacy series. Plus, there's a mix of Hulu originals and co-productions with others like Disney+ and FX.
If you're unsure where to start, we have devised this comprehensive list with all the top titles and a summary to give you an idea of what each show is about and what makes it so great. Have a read. We're sure you'll find something to add to your watchlist at home or on the go. If you have a Hulu plan without ads, you can even download it to watch offline on the plane or in the backseat of the car (with headphones!) for that spring road trip.

Need more recommendations? Then check out the best new shows to stream this week, as well as the best shows on Netflix, best shows on Amazon Prime Video, the best shows on Max, and the best shows on Disney+.

Read more